The Cast Photo courtesy of La Comedia Dinner Theatre

Jesus Christ Superstar is a retelling (with a number of liberties taken) of the last week of Jesus' life. The story is told from the perspectives of Jesus and Judas, starting just before their entrance into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday until Jesus' crucifixion. This version of the New Testament text attempts neither to confirm nor deny the divinity of Christ. Rather, it focuses on the humanity of Jesus. The character of Judas is written to personify the confusion, doubts, and fears of all of Jesus' followers. To the musical's detriment, the presentation of the story assumes that those in the audience know the tale, as few characters are sufficiently introduced. However, a high level of dramatic tension exists throughout to sustain sufficient interest in the story, and the presentation is likely to be thought-provoking for all and emotionally stirring for Christians.

Jesus Christ Superstar was one of the first sung-through, fully conceived book musicals using rock music. The score was by two relative unknowns (at the time), Andrew Lloyd Webber (music) and Tim Rice (lyrics). The music contains an effective mix of hard-driving rock rifts, wonderfully soulful ballads, and unique theatrical numbers. Rice's lyrics are extremely efficient, conveying the story along with the political and historical background of the time, all while achieving the high standards of musical theatre songwriting. "Heaven on Their Minds," "Everything's Alright," "I Don't Know How To Love Him," "Gethsemane," and the title song have become Broadway classics.

The cast for Jesus Christ Superstar at La Comedia is smaller than you might find elsewhere, with many of the supporting roles performed by actors also portraying one of the disciples. Josh Hamilton is a reserved Jesus, an appropriately stark contrast to the other characters. He sings in a more formal style rather than the rock voice often heard in the role, but he certainly hits all the right notes. His depiction of Jesus' agony during the crucifixion scene is heartbreaking and feels genuine. As Judas, Jonah Mendoza supplies wonderful vocal gymnastics well-suited to the part, and clearly conveys the torment and inner conflict of the character. Isabel Gray has some interesting interpretations vocally as Mary Magdalene, and brings the needed warmth and confusion to the role.

As Pontius Pilate, Heath Rawls is especially impressive delivering his material after Jesus' arrest, and Chad Ferriell displays great versatility and stage presence as King Herod. Colin Cranstoun possesses a beautifully rich bass voice which he puts to great use as Caiaphas, and Jonathan Pendergrass gives Annas some playful sass. Lee Fortner (Peter) and Kevin Ilardi (Simon The Zealot) shine in their primary moments. The entire hardworking ensemble deserves kudos for their dancing and vocal support.

Director and choreographer Chris Beiser supplies active blocking and several inventive ideas, including a particularly impactful way of staging "Trial Before Pilate (Including The 39 Lashes)." There are a few spots where opportunities to take cues from the lyrics, which could enhance the storytelling, are missed. Also, small costume changes could provide clarity when actors switch from being Jesus' supporters to the shouting mob during "The Arrest." Overall, Mr. Beiser navigates his actors well as they switch among the many doubled and tripled roles, and his dances are apt and visually appealing throughout.

Scenic designer Gabe Davidson sets the show at a modern church under renovation, with several levels and surprising details, and just the right amount of projections. The stark and well-integrated lighting by Edward Huber features several notable effects and is highlighted during "This Jesus Must Die." The costumes by Emercita Erb and Mattison Williams are varied and include many fun touches.

It's fitting that La Comedia's production Jesus Christ Superstar began during Holy Week, as it covers that same period in Jesus' life. This staging features excellent singers, worthwhile design, and praiseworthy direction.

Jesus Christ Superstar continues through May 10, 2026, at La Comedia Dinner Theater, 765 W. Central Ave, Springboro OH. For tickets and information, please call 937-746-4554 or visit lacomedia.com.