Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Other Regions

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein
Utah Shakespeare Festival
Review by Gil Benbrook

Also see Gil's reviews of Troilus and Cressida, See How They Run, She Loves Me, Something Rotten!, Hamlet and Harmony


Jacob Dresch and Emily Fury Daly
Photo by Karl Hugh
David Catlin's drama, Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, which premiered in 2019 at Chicago's Lookingglass Theatre, may prove to be a surprising play for anyone who is only familiar with the 1931 Universal monster film adaptation that featured Boris Karloff's grunting creature. Catlin's work is an emotionally charged drama that blends a somewhat straightforward adaptation of Shelley's classic 1818 Gothic novel with events in Shelley's own life, including how she first told her story to her friends, into an imaginative and passionate combination of theatricality and literature. The cast and creative team of Utah Shakespeare Festival's production embrace the novel and play's themes of creativity, creation, and responsibility, and the result is a quite moving, thought-provoking, and somewhat haunting piece of theatre that brings Shelley's haunting world and characters to life.

The play begins on a stormy evening in Switzerland in 1816 when Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin and her friends, including her stepsister and Lord Byron, are telling ghost stories, with a bet for who can tell the best one. At first, Mary's companion, Percy Bysshe Shelley (they would marry later that year), doesn't think Mary has the ability to craft a good ghost story, yet her tale of the brilliant but obsessive young scientist Victor Frankenstein, who creates a being from assembled body parts, proves to be a heartbreaking story of obsession, creation, and a creature in search of acceptance.

Catlin's play is a fairly faithful adaptation of Shelley's novel and is quite good, especially in how it blends together theatricality, literature, history, and philosophical questions. It's also a beautifully structured play within a play. When Mary begins to tell her story, Mary's friends, at first, simply play-act the parts of various characters in Mary's tale. But Catlin also weave events from Mary's life, including the death of her mother and her and Percy's children, by pulling them into the narrative as Mary's friends and the stage transform into a seamless mixture of the characters and events in Mary's novel and the people in her life. The real and fictitious stories morph back and forth throughout. In this regard, Catlin masterfully shows how situations and personal experiences are sometimes echoed in a writer's work. Catlin also peppers the piece with many well-written pieces of dialogue and does a wonderful job depicting how, perhaps, Victor was not the hero but the villain of the story, and the actual monster of the piece.

The cast are wonderful, especially Emily Fury Daly and Jacob Dresch, who play Mary and Percy as well as the novel's characters Victor and Elizabeth Lavenza, respectively. Their accent work is polished and the nuances and layers they bring to the roles they depict are superb. Travis Ascione paints a stirring portrait of the Creature that depicts layers of vulnerability, while Regan Sims and Sean Dale play an assortment of supporting roles with expertise.

Risa Brainin's direction derives distinct and rich portrayals from the entire cast and her staging makes great use of the entire auditorium, including the stairs in the seating sections and the entryways, to give an immersive feeling to the production. Rather than relying on elaborate special effects, the evocative music and sound design by Melanie Chen Cole, Claire Chrzan's sensational lighting, the inventive and effective set by Jason Simms, Devon Painter's period costumes, and the performances of a gifted cast, interweave to create a memorable theatrical experience.

Like the famous novel, David Catlin's Mary Shelley's Frankenstein allows the audience to see how characters often exist in shades of grey, neither hero nor villain, which allows us to sympathize with them while understanding the potentially tragic choices they've made. While those who are only familiar with the film adaptations, or who are expecting a more thrilling horror tale with a lot of shock effects, may be disappointed or surprised with the more introspective interpretation on hand, Catlin's play and Utah Shakespeare Festival's production honor the legacy and enduring power of Shelley's work while also reminding audiences that true monsters aren't often born of science but from the failure to take responsibility for one's actions; as Mary states toward the end, "are there not monsters in all of us?"

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein runs through October 3, 2026, at Utah Shakespeare Festival, with performances at the Beverley Taylor Sorenson Center for the Arts on the campus of Southern Utah University, 195 W Center St, Cedar City UT. For tickets and information, please visit www.bard.org or call 800-752-9849.

Director: Risa Brainin
Scenic Designer: Jason Simms
Costume Designer: Devon Painter
Lighting Designer: Claire Chrzan
Sound Designer/Original Music Composer: Melanie Chen Cole
Voice/Text/Dialect Coach: Steven Eng
Fight Director/Intimacy Coordinator/Choreographer: Christina Traister
Stage Manager: Emily Marie Wilke*
Assistant Stage Manager: Lauren Myers

Cast:
Mary Wollstonecraft Godwin/Elizabeth Lavenza: Emily Fury Daly*
Claire Clairmont/Portuguese Sailor/Mother/Villager/Sofia/Angel of Death/William/Woman in Black/Wedding Officiant: Regan Sims*
Percy Bysshe Shelley/Victor Frankenstein/Felix: Jacob Dresch*
Lord Byron/Scottish Sailor/Professor Waldman/The Creature: Travis Ascione
Dr. John Polidori/Walton/Henry Clerval/DeLacey: Sean Dale * Member of Actors' Equity Association, the union of professional actors and stage managers in the United States