Past Reviews

Regional Reviews: Raleigh/Durham

You Can't Take It with You
PlayMakers Repertory Company
Review by Garrett Southerland


The Cast
Photo by HuthPhoto
The classic American comedy You Can't Take It with You by Moss Hart and George S. Kaufman ushers in the holiday season with PlayMakers Repertory Company's production playing through December 7 at the Joan H. Gillings Center for Performing Arts on the campus of UNC. It is a joyous treat that reminds us of the famous saying usually attributed to Maya Angelou, "Life is not measured by the number of breaths we take, but the moments that take our breath away."

First produced in 1936, You Can't Take It with You won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1937 and was adapted into an Academy Award winning film in 1938. Its eccentric family continues to resonate with audiences almost a century later.

The story centers around the delightfully unconventional Vanderhof/Sycamore/Carmichael household. It is a bustling home filled with creativity, chaos, and unapologetic individuality. The household is headed by Grandpa Vanderhof (Ray Anthony Thomas), an eccentric and carefree man who hasn't paid income tax in years. His daughter, Penny (a delightful Julia Gibson), writes eclectic plays while her husband, Paul Sycamore (Trevor Johnson), is an inventor who has collaborated with his former iceman, Mr. De Pinna (Jim Bray), in creating homemade fireworks. Their eldest daughter, Essie (Elizabeth Dye), makes candy but dreams of becoming a ballerina and is married to Ed Carmichael (Matthew Donahue), a printer by trade but he also enjoys playing the xylophone. The youngest daughter, Alice (a charming Delaney Jackson), is the most practical member of the family and is often embarrassed by her relatives but loves them deeply. She has fallen in love with a coworker, Tony Kirby (Reez Bailey), who happens to be the son of the boss. She hopes her family will make a good impression on him and his parents' visit to the home while, at the same time, the IRS and federal agents are keeping an eye on the family's bohemian lifestyle.

Under the direction of Nathaniel P. Claridad, the production moves with excited fluidity. Daniel Zimmerman's scenic design is beautifully put together with every attention given to detail. It is an intricate collage of artifacts that looks like a museum but with a homey feel. A mechanical invention that provides water for Mrs. Sycamore's plants was an immediate crowd pleaser. Anne Kennedy's costume design serves the play well and Derek A. Graham's sound design provides a fitting musical soundtrack of early 20th century music. Graham also provides explosive sounds to the beautiful lighting design of Kathy A. Perkins that provides bursts of color and excitement when fireworks go off, figuratively and literally.

This production invites nostalgia and explores timeless themes. It is easy to see the play as a precursor to other stories with a plot of introducing a romantic partner to an embarrassing family, whether it is in the play Auntie Mame or the holiday film The Family Stone. Its warmth, wit and humor make this play an enduring favorite that anyone would enjoy.

You Can't Take It with You, presented by PlayMakers Repertory Company, runs through December 7, 2025, at the Joan H. Gillings Center for Performing Arts, 120 Country Club Road, Chapel Hill NC. For tickets and information, please visit www.playmakersrep.org or call 919-962-7529.

Playwrights: Moss Hart and George S. Kaufman
Direction: Nathaniel P. Claridad
Scenic Design: Daniel Zimmerman
Costume Design: Anne Kennedy
Lighting Design: Kathy A. Perkins
Sound Design: Derek A. Graham
Fight and Violence Choreography: Jeff A.R. Jones

Cast:
Tony Kirby: Reez Bailey
Government Agent: Dawson Boudreaux
Mr. De Pinna: Jim Bray
Boris Kolenkhov: Jeffrey Blair Cornell
Ed: Matthew Donahue
Essie: Elizabeth Dye
Penelope Sycamore: Julia Gibson
Mr. Kirby: Douglas S. Hall
Mrs. Kirby: Kathryn Hunter-Williams
Alice: Delaney Jackson
Rheba: Jadah Johnson
Paul Sycamore: Trevor Johnson
Donald: Nate John Mark
Government Agent: Caroline Marques
Government Agent: Trevele Morgan
Henderson: Adam Moskowitz
Government Agent: Celeste Pelletier
Olga: Gwendolyn Schwinke
Martin Vanderhof: Ray Anthony Thomas
Gay Wellington: Mengwe Wapimewah