Zachary Keller and Helen Krushinski Photo by Matthew Murphy

Water For Elephants is based on the 2006 novel by Sara Gruen, which was later adapted into a 2011 film, all of the same name. The musical follows the story of Jacob Jankowski, an elderly man living in an assisted living home, who visits a circus passing through time. After the show, he shares with some of the staff that he was a veterinarian in 1931 for the fabled Benzini Brothers Circus. Through a series of flashbacks, he tells of his adventures training an elephant named Rosie and of meeting a colorful collection of circus folk.

The book for the musical by Rick Elice (Jersey Boys, The Addams Family) is engaging, introduces unique characters and storylines (including many tied to circus life during the Depression), and often tugs at the heartstrings without being overbearing or disingenuous. While the show loses a bit of focus in Act 2, the book is overall a commendable one with much to offer theatregoers.

Many Broadway shows possess a score that is an asset, but have a book that lets it down. Water For Elephants is the opposite. The songs just aren't up to the level needed for a Broadway musical. The score by Pigpen Theatre Co., a New York City based indie folk band, features songs that aren't hard to listen to, but which ultimately could and should be better. Musically, there are several numbers with hypnotic, folksy melodies, but those too often meander. The lyrics are too repetitive, and there are many false-rhymes and unsophisticated (by Broadway standards) phrases. A more seasoned songwriter could have lifted a show to a higher level. The best songs in the show are "Anywhere/Another Train," "The Grand Spec," and "Wild."

The direction by Jessica Stone is brisk, appropriately tension-filled, and accessible. The incorporation of a variety of circus arts (juggling, tumbling, aerials, etc.) is wonderful. The use of masks, costumes, and puppetry to convey the various circus animals is likewise effective and a true asset to the production. The choreography by Jesse Robb and Shana Carroll includes dance and circus work, both of which add visual flair and variety to the proceedings. Sarah Pool Wilhelm directs a lively eight-piece band.

Robert Tully is a talented storyteller and provides spunk and a sense of awe as older Jacob, though he feels too young for the role. As younger Jacob, Zachary Keller demonstrates a gorgeous and booming singing voice. He's extremely likable in this leading performance, and captures many layers of the character. Helen Krushinski sings beautifully and embodies the strength and dignity as Marlena, the elephant trainer and possible love interest for young Jacob. Connor Sullivan is suitably menacing as the controlling Ringmaster and circus owner August, and shows off strong stage presence.

In supporting roles, Javier Garcia supplies pleasing vocals and a sympathetic character as Carmel, and Tyler West demonstrates many talents as Walter, including masterful clowning, fine singing, and first-rate acting chops. Chris Marth (Wade) and Ruby Gibbs (Barbara) also shine in their primary moments. The circus performers cover a wide array of skill, adding thrills to the stage at every turn. Though not listed in the program, world-class juggler Eric Bates deserves kudos for his cigar box work while filling in temporarily on tour. The remaining ensemble are all talented and hardworking.

The striking scenic design by Takeshi Kata is visually stunning, with vibrant colors, fascinating circus elements, and a noteworthy attention to detail. The costumes by David I. Reynoso are period appropriate and fun, and the lighting by Bradley King is professionally rendered and versatile. The puppetry design by Ray Wetmore, JR Goodman, and Camille Labarre earns special mention for its beauty and functionality.

Water For Elephants is a fine addition to the stable of touring Broadway shows, and does contain a lot of things to admire and enjoy. The current tour also boasts a talented cast of theatre and circus performers. One only wishes the audience could leave with more memorable (and better) songs in their heads.

Water For Elephants continues through May 3, 2026 at the Aronoff Center, 650 Walnut St., Cincinnati OH. For tickets and information, call 513-621-2787 or visit cincinnati.broadway.com. For more information on the tour, visit https://waterforelephantsthemusical.com/.

NOTE: In addition to over twenty-five years as a musical theatre critic, writer Scott Cain is also a former circus performer and professional juggler, and a leading juggling / circus historian.