|
Regional Reviews: Phoenix The Pillowman Also see Gil's reviews of Eureka Day and Pippin
The story centers on Katurian, a writer of gruesome short stories who is brought in for questioning by the police after a series of child murders bears disturbing similarities to events in her works. As Detective Tupolski leads the interrogation, and his more volatile partner, Ariel, applies violently aggressive pressure, Katurian attempts to convince them that she has nothing to do with the murders and that her stories are simply works of her imagination rather than instructions for a murderer to act upon. The situation becomes even more complicated when Katurian is told that her brother Michal, who has an intellectual disability, is being interrogated in the room next door. As the questioning unfolds and revelations are revealed, the distinction between truth and fiction becomes increasingly blurred. In The Pillowman, McDonagh explores the power of storytelling and the complicated relationship between art and real life, asking whether writers can be held responsible for the actions their work may inspire, especially if it's the violent events in the writer's past that motivated their creation. The play also examines the lasting effects of childhood trauma and the lengths to which someone will go to protect those they love. Through Katurian's disturbing tales and the increasingly unsettling revelations surrounding her past and her family, McDonagh challenges audiences to consider whether stories can offer an escape from suffering or provoke the violence they depict. However, while The Pillowman and this production are gripping, there are some aspects of the play that may leave audiences less enthusiastic. The relentless darkness and trauma may become exhausting to some as it piles one disturbing imagery of child abuse, torture, murder, or psychological cruelty on top of another. That constant grimness can become numbing, and the violence in the stories is so extreme at times that there is a risk of seeming designed primarily to shock and provoke rather than deepen the audience's understanding of the characters or the themes McDonagh has baked into his play. Also, while the ending is satisfying, it doesn't necessarily offer any easy answers, leaving audiences to wrestle with the boundaries between imagination and reality and between compassion and cruelty. The cast and direction in Fifth Wall's production are excellent. As Katurian, Melody Knudson delivers a portrayal that walks the delicate balance of intelligence, vulnerability, and determination beautifully. Knudson makes Katurian's desperation to protect her stories and her brother both believable and affecting with an appropriate urgency in her portrayal. As the detective, Tupolski, CJ Mascarelli projects a powerful strength along with a perfectly controlled demeanor and comically dark observations that provide a sharp contrast to the aggressive, unpredictable approach that Marcel Williams brings to Arial. Knudson, Mascarelli, and Williams invest their roles with distinctive personalities and strong dramatic presence. As Michal, Rob Evans is fantastic, bringing emotional complexity to a character whose relationship with Katurian becomes central to the play's most troubling revelations. Together, along with the supporting cast composed of Angelia Saario, Carol Gibson, Izaya Claron Emmanuel, and Carlin Thomas, they form a tight ensemble that propels the plot forward. Richard Powers-Hardt's direction brings the action close enough to the audience that we sometimes feel like flies on the wall of the interrogation room, witnessing events that are both intimate and deeply uncomfortable. His staging makes effective use of the space, and the minimal set works well for the bare, institutional environment the story requires. The only quibble I have is in the use of two flats behind which much of the reenactment of Katurian's stories takes place. Maybe Stewart's bare lighting and the staging occasionally make it somewhat difficult to see the ensemble member's movements clearly behind these screens, obscuring some details that would otherwise enhance the experience. However, Stewart's lighting of the main stage area is fantastic, so it could just be due to a limitation of the space. Despite that minor staging issue, with committed performances and effective direction, The Pillowman at Fifth Wall Playhouse is a gripping production of a story that will most likely linger in your mind while it also confronts you with its unsettling questions. The Pillowman runs through October 18, 2026, at Fifth Wall Playhouse, with performances at with performances at the Arizona Opera Center, 1636 N. Central Avenue, Phoenix AZ. For tickets and information, please visit 5thwallplayhouse.com. Director: Richard Powers-Hardt Cast: |
